Breathing in a Plague

exc-5fbb687d317ba51462319ea4

27 NOVEMBER 2020 • By TMR

Untitled drawing by artist  Roshanak Aminelahi , pen on cardboard, 20 x 20 centimeters (2018).

Selîm Temo

 
In the third volume of his memoirs Breath: A Decision*, Thomas Bernhard writes about spending time in a hospital ward for the nearly dead after contracting a severe lung infection caused by influenza. Though he was only eighteen years old, he was placed in a geriatric ward full of old men “whose death was judged imminent [when they] were taken out of the ward along the corridor to the bathroom”—a blinding, fluorescent-lit bathroom for those whose light is about to go out. When it is young Thomas’ turn to be brought to the bathroom, he starts to think about what he should do to show that he is still alive. He moves his fingers, but this may as well be seen as a postmortem spasm and the person who would take him to the bright room might not regard this reflex as a strong enough sign of life. Finally, it occurs to him to breathe. He breathes, persistently breathes.

• • •

My son, who ran around to find a stretcher for me, held my hand and told me the same sentence that I had uttered to him years ago: “Don’t be afraid!” Eighteen years ago, he didn’t understand what “Don’t be afraid!” meant, because he didn’t speak a single word yet. Through his lungs, collapsed because of high pressure, the breath he was exhaling and inhaling was filling up his belly like an expanding and contracting bellow. With great difficulty, I took him from the poor maternity ward to a private hospital. The tube connected to the ventilator went into the left side of his chest and resuscitated him. His fingers—that now move with ease over the strings of his guitar—were not quite as long back then. He was barely holding onto my pinkie that I thrust through the incubator’s tiny opening. Last year when I felt his hands while on the stretcher, I remembered that moment of his feeble breathing.

The second thing I remembered was Bernhard’s breath, he who never forgave the Austrians for greeting the Nazis in Leipzig with so much gusto and who prevented his books from being sold in Austria. And the young Thomas’s breath that became the only solid proof of life once let out. 

In the intensive care unit where I stayed, there were patients with serious conditions. It was like a morgue for the living. An elderly man looked as if he were waiting for judgement day. He didn’t seem to be in a hurry as he fulfilled his religious duties. Without any reaction, he was watching the injections, check-ups, and blood pressure measures, breathing in and out like a rural public officer waiting in line patiently.

On my left, a woman whose body had abandoned her was constantly uncovering herself. The sense of privacy that was long gone for her still existed in me, so I didn’t look at her again, but tried to hear her. She was sometimes acting as if she were throwing off the broken Turkish sentences and returning to Kurdish, to the language of a life she abandoned or as if she wanted to live once again. 

The man on my right seemed to be concerned only about the part of his body that breathed. With his body stiffened like a horse at the edge of life, he was only breathing through his nose. He was alive, but about to be taken to the bright room.

I supposed there was ice gel on my back. I couldn’t stop shivering. Somehow, I wasn’t able to feel any warmth toward my own body that just tried to abandon me. Also no one was treating me like someone with a body.

At the wee hours, they brought in someone around fifty-five years old whose lungs had collapsed. His chest was like a blacksmith’s bellow, rising up and down. His body was shaking so uncontrollably that the tubes, lines and valve sockets in various colors and shapes kept coming off. His hands and feet also looked as if they were about to break off from his heaving chest and burst open onto the faces of the nurses with slender wrists. These were more like the muscle movements of a dead person than those of a living one.  

The medical staff came to tell me that they had to move me to another bed to accommodate a newly arrived patient since my bed was attached to a machine that the other beds weren’t. They took me to the right side of the door and to the left side of the man with collapsed lungs. They attached fewer cables to my body, put another blanket on me, and then I started to breathe deeper. A friend of mine who worked as a doctor at the same hospital came in with a poetry book in his hands thinking that I could read poetry there! I thanked him and asked if he could move me to a private room, only if he thought I was well enough to be moved. I heard the news that the patient who was given my bed died shortly after I was finally brought to another room. The echo left by his hands and feet that were no longer his kept beating up my consciousness all night long.

 • • •

I haven’t smoked since that day and have been treating this gift of second life well.

When various professionals on duty announced that the intensive care units had almost reached capacity, if not already, and that the doctors had to choose who to let live and who to let die, I thought about three things: My little son who had clung onto my pinkie with his four tiny fingers, young Thomas who unveils his aliveness through breathing, and my breath bestowed on me for the second time. 

If you ask me, what is collapsing is not only the medical system, but civilization. The members of the Frankfurt School were preaching the “promesse du bonheur” that they borrowed from Stendhal and yet the Nazis arrived! This pandemic seems to signal the digital dictatorship. 1984 might come, “with a little delay,” in 2024.

Those in power advise us to stay home and not visit the emergency rooms. However, this collapse is caused by them. As eager to kill their own citizens as well as others, they can’t handle this infection since they seem to thrive on death, not life. For this reason, if we survive this pandemic through solidarity with each other, we should go out to protect the world bestowed upon us for the second time and breathe together. This is how we can prove that we are alive.

 * Published in English as volume 3 out of 5 in Bernhard’s autobiography, Gathering Evidence.

This essay first appeared in Kurdish as “A Breath” in Xwebûn and appears here translated by Selîm Temo and Öykü Tekten, with translation appreciation to Miriam Atkin and kudos to Ammiel Alcalay for the introduction to TMR.

Poet, translator and scholar Selîm Temo.

Born in Mêrîna, Batman in 1972, Selîm Temo is a Kurdish poet, scholar, translator, and editor. Temo studied Anthropology in Ankara University (BA) and Turkish Literature (MA) in Bilkent University where he also received his PhD degree. He has authored more than thirty books, including Kurdish or Turkish poetry, translations, anthologies, children’s books, novels, and news articles. Temo is currently a visiting scholar in Paul Valéry University of Montpellier.

TMR

Join Our Community

TMR exists thanks to its readers and supporters. By sharing our stories and celebrating cultural pluralism, we aim to counter racism, xenophobia, and exclusion with knowledge, empathy, and artistic expression.

Learn more

RELATED

Book Reviews

Hope Without Hope: Rojava and Revolutionary Commitment

11 JULY 2025 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Hope Without Hope: Rojava and Revolutionary Commitment
Art

Repression and Resistance in the Work of Artist Ateş Alpar

27 JUNE 2025 • By Jennifer Hattam
Repression and Resistance in the Work of Artist Ateş Alpar
History

Ahlat Reimagined—Birthplace of Turkish Rule in Anatolia

29 NOVEMBER 2024 • By William Gourlay
Ahlat Reimagined—Birthplace of Turkish Rule in Anatolia
Opinion

Should a Climate-Destroying Dictatorship Host a Climate-Saving Conference?

25 OCTOBER 2024 • By Lucine Kasbarian
Should a Climate-Destroying Dictatorship Host a Climate-Saving Conference?
Essays

Who Decides What Makes for Authentic Middle East Fiction?

6 SEPTEMBER 2024 • By Nektaria Anastasiadou
Who Decides What Makes for Authentic Middle East Fiction?
Essays

Beyond Rubble—Cultural Heritage and Healing After Disaster

23 AUGUST 2024 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Beyond Rubble—Cultural Heritage and Healing After Disaster
Essays

SPECIAL KURDISH ISSUE: From Kurmanji to English, an Introduction to Selim Temo

9 AUGUST 2024 • By Zêdan Xelef
SPECIAL KURDISH ISSUE: From Kurmanji to English, an Introduction to Selim Temo
Book Reviews

Woe to the Conquered: Selim Temo’s Nightlands

9 AUGUST 2024 • By Jordan Elgrably
Woe to the Conquered: Selim Temo’s <em>Nightlands</em>
Book Reviews

Wandering and Endless Sorrow: Farhad Pirbal’s The Potato Eaters

9 AUGUST 2024 • By Cory Oldweiler
Wandering and Endless Sorrow: Farhad Pirbal’s <em>The Potato Eaters</em>
Book Reviews

Life Along Istanbul’s Byzantine Walls, a Review

28 JUNE 2024 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Life Along Istanbul’s Byzantine Walls, a Review
Book Reviews

The Myth of the West: A Discontinuous History

3 MARCH 2024 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
The Myth of the West: A Discontinuous History
Art & Photography

Cyprus: Return to Petrofani with Ali Cherri & Vicky Pericleous

8 JANUARY 2024 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Cyprus: Return to Petrofani with Ali Cherri & Vicky Pericleous
Art

The Apocalypse is a Dance Party

8 JANUARY 2024 • By Sena Başöz
The Apocalypse is a Dance Party
Poetry

Two Poems by Efe Duyan

22 DECEMBER 2023 • By Efe Duyan, Aron Aji
Two Poems by Efe Duyan
Books

On the Herculean Task of Translating Joyce’s Ulysses into Kurdish

28 NOVEMBER 2023 • By Kaya Genç
On the Herculean Task of Translating Joyce’s <em>Ulysses</em> into Kurdish
Book Reviews

First Kurdish Sci-Fi Collection is Rooted in the Past

28 NOVEMBER 2023 • By Matt Broomfield
First Kurdish Sci-Fi Collection is Rooted in the Past
Essays

Rebuilding After the Quake: a Walk Down Memory Lane in Southeast Anatolia

5 NOVEMBER 2023 • By Sevinç Ünal
Rebuilding After the Quake: a Walk Down Memory Lane in Southeast Anatolia
Interviews

Illegitimate Literature—Interview with Novelist Ebru Ojen

18 SEPTEMBER 2023 • By Nazlı Koca
Illegitimate Literature—Interview with Novelist Ebru Ojen
Book Reviews

Kurdish Novel Explores Nightmarish Isolation in Eastern Anatolia

18 SEPTEMBER 2023 • By Kaya Genç
Kurdish Novel Explores Nightmarish Isolation in Eastern Anatolia
Art

Anatolian Journey: a Writer Travels to Sultan Han to Witness a Postmodern Installation

18 SEPTEMBER 2023 • By Matt Hanson
Anatolian Journey: a Writer Travels to Sultan Han to Witness a Postmodern Installation
Fiction

“Sweet Tea”—a classic Kurdish story by Hussein Arif

3 SEPTEMBER 2023 • By Hussein Arif, Jiyar Homer
“Sweet Tea”—a classic Kurdish story by Hussein Arif
Book Reviews

Traveling Through Turkey With Gertrude Bell and Pat Yale

28 AUGUST 2023 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Traveling Through Turkey With Gertrude Bell and Pat Yale
Opinion

The Middle East is Once Again West Asia

14 AUGUST 2023 • By Chas Freeman, Jr.
The Middle East is Once Again West Asia
Book Reviews

Can the Kurdish Women’s Movement Transform the Middle East?

31 JULY 2023 • By Matt Broomfield
Can the Kurdish Women’s Movement Transform the Middle East?
Book Reviews

Literature Takes Courage: on Ahmet Altan’s Lady Life

24 JULY 2023 • By Kaya Genç
Literature Takes Courage: on Ahmet Altan’s <em>Lady Life</em>
Interviews

Musical Artists at Work: Naïssam Jalal, Fazil Say & Azu Tiwaline

17 JULY 2023 • By Jordan Elgrably
Musical Artists at Work: Naïssam Jalal, Fazil Say & Azu Tiwaline
Art & Photography

The Ghost of Gezi Park—Turkey 10 Years On

19 JUNE 2023 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
The Ghost of Gezi Park—Turkey 10 Years On
Art & Photography

Deniz Goran’s New Novel Contrasts Art and the Gezi Park Protests

19 JUNE 2023 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Deniz Goran’s New Novel Contrasts Art and the Gezi Park Protests
Book Reviews

Niki, Prize-Winning Greek Novel, Captures the Country’s Civil War

12 JUNE 2023 • By Nektaria Anastasiadou
<em>Niki</em>, Prize-Winning Greek Novel, Captures the Country’s Civil War
Essays

Turkey’s Earthquake as a Generational Disaster

4 JUNE 2023 • By Sanem Su Avci
Turkey’s Earthquake as a Generational Disaster
Poetry Markaz

Zara Houshmand, Moon and Sun

4 JUNE 2023 • By Zara Houshmand
Zara Houshmand, <em>Moon and Sun</em>
Film

The Refugees by the Lake, a Greek Migrant Story

8 MAY 2023 • By Iason Athanasiadis
The Refugees by the Lake, a Greek Migrant Story
Essays

Beautiful Ghosts, or We’ll Always Have Istanbul

27 MARCH 2023 • By Alicia Kismet Eler
Beautiful Ghosts, or We’ll Always Have Istanbul
Cities

For Those Who Dwell in Tents, Home is Temporal—Or Is It?

5 MARCH 2023 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
For Those Who Dwell in Tents, Home is Temporal—Or Is It?
Columns

Letter From Turkey—Solidarity, Grief, Anger and Fear

27 FEBRUARY 2023 • By Jennifer Hattam
Letter From Turkey—Solidarity, Grief, Anger and Fear
Columns

Letter From Turkey—Antioch is Finished

20 FEBRUARY 2023 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
Letter From Turkey—Antioch is Finished
Art

Art World Picks: Albraehe, Kerem Yavuz, Zeghidour, Amer & Tatah

12 DECEMBER 2022 • By TMR
Opinion

Attack on Salman Rushdie is Shocking Tip of the Iceberg

15 AUGUST 2022 • By Jordan Elgrably
Attack on Salman Rushdie is Shocking Tip of the Iceberg
Columns

World Refugee Day — What We Owe Each Other

20 JUNE 2022 • By Jordan Elgrably
World Refugee Day — What We Owe Each Other
Fiction

Nektaria Anastasiadou: “Gold in Taksim Square”

15 JUNE 2022 • By Nektaria Anastasiadou
Nektaria Anastasiadou: “Gold in Taksim Square”
Featured excerpt

Bakhtiyar Ali: “The Prisoner and the Plague”

15 JUNE 2022 • By Bakytiyar Ali
Bakhtiyar Ali: “The Prisoner and the Plague”
Film Reviews

2022 Webby Honoree Documents Queer Turkish Icon

23 MAY 2022 • By Ilker Hepkaner
2022 Webby Honoree Documents Queer Turkish Icon
Book Reviews

Mohamed Metwalli’s “A Song by the Aegean Sea” Reviewed

28 MARCH 2022 • By Sherine Elbanhawy
Mohamed Metwalli’s “A Song by the Aegean Sea” Reviewed
Art & Photography

On “True Love Leaves No Traces”

15 MARCH 2022 • By Arie Amaya-Akkermans
On “True Love Leaves No Traces”
Art & Photography

Children in Search of Refuge: a Photographic Essay

15 JANUARY 2022 • By Iason Athanasiadis
Children in Search of Refuge: a Photographic Essay
Columns

Getting to the Other Side: a Kurdish Migrant Story

15 JANUARY 2022 • By Iason Athanasiadis
Getting to the Other Side: a Kurdish Migrant Story
Columns

Burning Forests, Burning Nations

15 NOVEMBER 2021 • By Hadani Ditmars
Burning Forests, Burning Nations
Columns

Day of the Imprisoned Writer — November 15, 2021

8 NOVEMBER 2021 • By TMR
Day of the Imprisoned Writer — November 15, 2021
Columns

Kurdish Poet and Writer Meral Şimşek Merits Her Freedom

4 OCTOBER 2021 • By Jordan Elgrably
Kurdish Poet and Writer Meral Şimşek Merits Her Freedom
Art & Photography

Displaced: From Beirut to Los Angeles to Beirut

15 SEPTEMBER 2021 • By Ara Oshagan
Displaced: From Beirut to Los Angeles to Beirut
Essays

Why Resistance Is Foundational to Kurdish Literature

15 SEPTEMBER 2021 • By Ava Homa
Why Resistance Is Foundational to Kurdish Literature
Featured excerpt

The Harrowing Life of Kurdish Freedom Activist Kobra Banehi

15 SEPTEMBER 2021 • By Kobra Banehi, Jordan Elgrably
The Harrowing Life of Kurdish Freedom Activist Kobra Banehi
Latest Reviews

The Limits of Empathy in Rabih Alameddine’s Refugee Saga

15 SEPTEMBER 2021 • By Dima Alzayat
The Limits of Empathy in Rabih Alameddine’s Refugee Saga
Latest Reviews

Women Comic Artists, from Afghanistan to Morocco

15 AUGUST 2021 • By Sherine Hamdy
Women Comic Artists, from Afghanistan to Morocco
Latest Reviews

An Anthropologist Tells of 1970s Upheaval in “Turkish Kaleidoscope”

15 AUGUST 2021 • By Jenny White
An Anthropologist Tells of 1970s Upheaval in “Turkish Kaleidoscope”
Weekly

World Picks: August 2021

12 AUGUST 2021 • By Lawrence Joffe
World Picks: August 2021
Weekly

Summer of ‘21 Reading—Notes from the Editors

25 JULY 2021 • By TMR
Summer of ‘21 Reading—Notes from the Editors
Weekly

World Picks: July 2021

3 JULY 2021 • By TMR
World Picks: July 2021
Essays

We Are All at the Border Now

14 MAY 2021 • By Todd Miller
We Are All at the Border Now
Fiction

A Home Across the Azure Sea

14 MAY 2021 • By Aida Y. Haddad
A Home Across the Azure Sea
Interviews

The Hidden World of Istanbul’s Rums

21 FEBRUARY 2021 • By Rana Haddad
The Hidden World of Istanbul’s Rums
TMR 6 • Revolutions

Revolution Viewed from the Crow’s Nest of History

15 FEBRUARY 2021 • By Melissa Chemam
Revolution Viewed from the Crow’s Nest of History
Columns

Remember 2020 Not for Covid-19 or Trump Chaos, But Climate Change

10 JANUARY 2021 • By Iason Athanasiadis
Remember 2020 Not for Covid-19 or Trump Chaos, But Climate Change
Weekly

Academics, Signatories, and Putschists

20 DECEMBER 2020 • By Selim Temo
Academics, Signatories, and Putschists
Weekly

Assaulting Free Speech in the Israel/Palestine Debate

6 DECEMBER 2020 • By TMR
Assaulting Free Speech in the Israel/Palestine Debate
Weekly

The Unbearable Affront of Colorism

30 NOVEMBER 2020 • By Banah Al Ghadbanah
The Unbearable Affront of Colorism
Weekly

Breathing in a Plague

27 NOVEMBER 2020 • By TMR
Breathing in a Plague
Weekly

Arabs and Muslims on Stage: Can We Unpack Our Baggage?

24 NOVEMBER 2020 • By TMR
Arabs and Muslims on Stage: Can We Unpack Our Baggage?
Beirut

An Outsider’s Long Goodbye

15 SEPTEMBER 2020 • By Annia Ciezadlo
An Outsider’s Long Goodbye
What We're Into

Dismantlings and Exile

14 SEPTEMBER 2020 • By Francisco Letelier
Dismantlings and Exile

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eleven + sixteen =

Scroll to Top